For a generation of British investors, property seemed the obvious answer. Bricks and mortar, the thinking went, never let you down. But a growing number of landlords are asking whether it's time to sell their buy-to-lets, and the arithmetic may surprise them. The right response starts with a plan.
There's a familiar ritual in the celebrity money interview. Somewhere near the end, the famous person is asked to name their best-ever investment, and the answer, more often than not, is a property. A house bought decades ago. A flat that multiplied in value while they got on with their career. It's a comfortable, faintly smug moment, and it has shaped how a lot of people think about money.
What that answer leaves out is almost everything that matters: inflation, the running costs and the years it took to get there. And if you're weighing up whether to sell your buy-to-let today, the sums look very different from the dinner-party version.
Few places absorbed the property faith more completely than Cambridge and the towns around it, and few show the change of heart more clearly. Tom Redmayne, a Chartered Financial Planner at rockwealth Cambridge, sees it across his client book. “The majority of my Cambridge clients have buy-to-let portfolios,” he says, “and the majority of them are starting to look to wind down.” Many built those portfolios in easier times. “A lot of them came up through the golden era of property, when it made good sense: cheap, easy access to leverage. But now they feel their time, their money and in some cases their general wellbeing being squeezed.”
They are not alone. In the most recent English Private Landlord Survey, 31 per cent of landlords said they planned to reduce the size of their portfolio over the next two years, including 16 per cent who intended to sell up entirely. This article is about how to make that decision well, without taking sides over property as an asset class.
What your buy-to-let has really returned
Measured in real terms, national house-price growth has been far weaker over the past two decades than the headlines suggest. Analysis by Savills found that the average UK house price in September 2025 was 74% higher than in September 2005. Once inflation is stripped out, though, it was actually 2% lower in real terms.
It’s important to note, price growth is only half the story. A buy-to-let also earns its keep through rent, and rent arrives net of a long list of deductions: letting-agent fees, insurance, maintenance, the void periods between tenants and, thanks to Section 24, a potentially heavier tax bill for higher-rate individual landlords, who can no longer deduct their full mortgage interest and instead receive a basic-rate tax reduction.
Tom has run these numbers with clients, and the results land hard. “When you include the effects of inflation over the last 20 years or so, a lot of buy-to-lets have hardly wiped their feet in terms of what they've actually returned,” he says. “I've run through the numbers with clients in their portfolios, and it was news to them.”
The nominal figure is the one the dinner-party story remembers. The real, after-costs return is the one that funded, or failed to fund, the owner's future. They are rarely the same number.
What holding property really costs
If the returns are thinner than assumed, the costs of staying in are higher than they look, and not all of them show up on a statement. The case for holding buy-to-let has weakened on three fronts at once: the rulebook, the workload and the shape of the asset itself.
Start with the rulebook. In England, Part 1 of the Renters' Rights Act came into force on 1 May 2026 and scrapped Section 21 no-fault evictions. In England and Northern Ireland, the higher Stamp Duty Land Tax rates for additional properties are five percentage points above the standard residential rates, making buying or rebalancing materially more expensive. And tighter energy rules are coming: from 2030, rented homes will need an energy performance rating of C, a bill that can run to £10,000 under the government's cost cap for older stock. None of this is fatal on its own. Together it adds up to a sector that asks more of its owners than it used to.
Then there's the workload, easy to underestimate until it wakes you up. “Your portfolio won't call you at four in the morning with a burst pipe,” Tom says. Being a landlord is a part-time job, and it doesn't clock off for retirement.
The third front matters most for anyone approaching or already in retirement: the shape of the asset. A rental property concentrates a large slice of wealth in a single postcode and a single asset class, and it locks that wealth away just as access starts to matter. “It's great to have regular income from a property,” Tom says, “but you can't get at the capital if you want it. Taking the capital out and having that flexibility gives you options, and that's always a great place to be.” At this stage of life, liquidity means holidays taken while health allows, help given to children when it counts and care options kept open.
How a financial plan changes the decision
The decision deserves a proper plan before anything is sold. The more useful question is which properties, in what order, over what period, at what tax cost and in the service of what kind of life. As Tom puts it: “The planning work helps them put the right strategy in place: which properties, when, why, the tax implications, how to spread disposals out, the trade-off between the income they're getting and a capital injection, and what to do with that capital.”
Consider one couple he worked with. They came to him worried they weren’t going to be able to afford their desired lifestyle throughout retirement. The husband had been made redundant around the time of COVID and never went back to work, and the two of them had been living off cash, without having looked properly at their investments in years. They had convinced themselves their position was precarious. In fact, they own several rental properties in and around Cambridgeshire, along with a couple of properties overseas. The planning work showed they were fine. It also set out a schedule to sell one or two of the rentals and one of the overseas places over the coming years, freeing capital to enjoy life while they were, in his words, still relatively young, fit and healthy.
What changed for that couple was the permission the disposal schedule gave them. A plan turned a low, constant worry into a set of decisions they could live with.
Capital released from property has to go somewhere, of course. A globally diversified, low-cost portfolio offers the things a row of rental houses can't: money you can reach on any given day, no phone calls about boilers and a spread across thousands of companies rather than a handful of streets. The approach at rockwealth is built on exactly that kind of evidence-based investing.
Deciding whether to sell your buy-to-let
For anyone wondering where to begin, the questions themselves are knowable. Before selling anything, a landlord needs clear answers to a handful of them, and most portfolios have never been asked.
What has each property really returned, net of every cost and adjusted for inflation, over the years you've owned it? How much capital is tied up in it, and what would that money need to earn elsewhere to justify leaving it where it is? What would selling cost in tax, and does spreading disposals across different tax years change the answer? What does the rental income pay for now, and what would access to the capital make possible instead? And which property should go first? That last one is rarely obvious, because the answer mixes yield, gain, hassle and, if you're honest, sentiment.
These are the calculations a financial planner runs for a living. Most landlords have simply never had reason to run them, which is why the urge to sell so often stalls at a vague feeling rather than a decision.
Options are the real asset
The celebrity with the flat bought decades ago may well have been right. The answer was incomplete. The fuller version of the property story includes what the asset costs in real returns, in time and in capital you can't reach when you need it.
That still leaves room for property. “It's not to say property is wrong and you should never hold it,” Tom says. “It can still work well as part of an overall strategy. It's about being aware of the opportunity cost, especially when a lot of capital is tied up in the value of the house.”
What people approaching retirement want, in the end, is options: the freedom that comes from a plan you trust, with capital you can actually reach. Property can be part of that once it has earned its place.
If you'd like to talk to Tom Redmayne, Chartered Financial Planner at rockwealth Cambridge, about whether your buy-to-lets still deserve their place in your plan, why not arrange an initial meeting?